Heritage Auctions
Coin News
In This Issue:
Record-Setting 1895 Morgan Dollar and Top-Graded 1928 $5,000 Note Lead Heritage’s $22.1 Million Long Beach Expo Numismatic Auctions
Renowned Collector’s Trove of Toned Morgan Dollars Offers Eye-Catching Treasures in Heritage’s September 23 Showcase Auction
The Western Mining Ingot Collection September 29
Early Copper & Colonial Coinage Featured in September 23 Showcase Auction
Numismatic Literary Guild Honors Heritage Auctions for Best Software, Podcast and Catalogs
Help Wanted: Heritage Is Expanding
Around Heritage Auctions
This Week's Top Ten
Is It Time To Sell?
Current Auctions

September 17, 2024
Record-Setting 1895 Morgan Dollar and Top-Graded 1928 $5,000 Note Lead Heritage’s $22.1 Million Long Beach Expo Numismatic Auctions
1895 $1 PR67+ Deep Cameo PCGS. CAC
More than 30 bids poured in for an 1895 Morgan Dollar, PR67+ Deep Cameo before it sold for a record $324,000 to lead Heritage’s September 12-15 Long Beach Expo US Coins Signature® Auction to $11,544,441. Coupled with the $10,587,005 from Heritage’s September 11-13 Long Beach Expo US Currency Signature® Auction that was led by a Fr. 2220-E $5,000 1928 Federal Reserve Note. PMG Gem Uncirculated 65 EPQ lifted the combined total for the events to $22,131,446.

The result for the 1895 Morgan dollar smashed the previous record of $269,500.

“It is possible that as many as 12,000 circulation strike Morgan dollars were produced, but if there are any survivors, they have been kept well out of the public eye,” says Todd Imhof, Executive Vice President at Heritage Auctions. “This coin is one of just 880 Proofs that were struck, but most of them are well out of reach of the collecting community, too. This is a magnificent addition to any collection.”

Also popular among collectors was Major General Alexander Macomb’s Congressional Gold Medal, which drew 55 bids before closing at $240,000. Macomb was one of 27 War of 1812 veterans honored with the Congressional Gold Medal, which was engraved by Moritz Fürst and was one of several adorned with a battle scene on the reverse. Although bronze duplicates were struck for decades by the U.S. Mint, only Macomb’s personal specimen, which he received directly from the hands of former President James Madison, was struck in gold.

1909-O $5 MS64 PCGS. CAC. Variety 1
A 1909-O Indian Half Eagle, MS64, PCGS CAC Variety 1 ended at $216,000. Just 34,200 were struck in 1909, and the 1909-O Indian half eagle represents the only issue of Bela Lyon Pratt’s design ever struck at the historic facility. When the coins were released into circulation, a few high-quality examples were saved by contemporary collectors.

The auction included items from several collections, including the Duffy Family Collection that featured a bumper crop of silver and gold type coins in collector grades. Among the top lots from the collection was a 1907 Rolled Edge Eagle, AU55 PCGS, a beautiful example of the second-rarest issue in the entire series that drew a winning bid of $186,000. The Rolled Edge coins were meant to solve the problems of their Wire Rim pattern predecessors, but fell short; for example, the Rolled Edge coins usually were softly struck in the centers, and Mint Superintendent John Landis did not care for the design, which was soon abandoned in favor of the No Periods motif. This impressive Choice AU specimen is one of just 50 examples that were not melted before distribution.

A 1907 High Relief, Wire Rim Double Eagle, MS67star NGC, among the finest examples of this exceptional coin, finished at $168,000. Augustus Saint-Gaudens believed in the theory of conceiving an idea and then seeing it through, a methodical pace he followed when designing ten and twenty dollar coins at the request of President Theodore Roosevelt. NGC lists nearly three dozen High Reliefs in MS67 and associated Plus and Star grades, but most of those coins are reported for the Flat Rim variant. Wire Rim pieces are, curiously, rarer. NGC lists four Wire Rim coins in MS67, plus one in MS67+, this one in MS67star, and one in MS67+star, with two MS68s finer.

Also from the Duffy Collection comes a 1796 Capped Bust Right Quarter Eagle, AU50 PCGS that reached $152,400. This beauty is from a tiny mintage of just 963 pieces, and when the No Stars motif was abandoned later in the year, it made this coin a celebrated one-year design type that Ron Guth called “one of the most historic and important U.S. gold coins” and Q. David Bowers called “the rarest U.S. gold design.” John Dannreuther estimates the BD-2 dies were used to strike 897 pieces of the first-year mintage and the surviving population of the BD-2 variety is 100-125 examples in all grades.

A third prize from the Duffy Collection was a 1793 S-3 Cent, AU55, PCGS CAC that drew more than three dozen bids before it sold for $150,000. Examples of this quality are exceptionally rare: the population graded in 55 sits at just two, with one finer; CAC 1 in 55, with none finer.

Other top lots from the Long Beach Expo US Coins auction included, but were not limited to:
Complete results from the Long Beach Expo US Coins auction can be found at HA.com/1377.

Currency
Fr. 2220-E $5,000 1928 Federal Reserve Note. PMG Gem Uncirculated 65 EPQ
The Fr. 2220-E $5,000 1928 Federal Reserve Note. PMG Gem Uncirculated 65 EPQ that led the currency event comes from the Ronald R. Gustafson Collection, and is the finest PMG-graded Series 1928 in this denomination and the sole finest known 1928 $5,000 from any district. The PMG Population Report has graded just 22 Series 1928 $5,000s for all districts, and this note sits alone atop the list.

“We have seen a number of high-grade $5,000s in recent years, but all of those were from the 1934 Series, and none could compare in quality with this incredible note from the 1928 Series,” says Dustin Johnston, Vice President of Numismatics at Heritage Auctions. “The winning bidder won a magnificent note, perhaps the pinnacle of 20th century US type notes.”

Another high-denomination trophy in the auction was a Fr. 2230-E $10,000 1928 Federal Reserve Note. PMG About Uncirculated that drew a winning bid of $384,000. Series 1928 $10,000 notes are exceedingly rare — PMG has graded from among all districts only seven Series 1928 $10,000 notes, compared to 113 Series 1934 $10,000s. Census keepers experts have found just 10 Series 1928 representatives from all districts combined ... and even that number is deceptive, as the only New York and San Francisco examples are housed in the collection of the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, meaning just eight remain in the possession of collectors, and of those, this magnificent example carries the second-highest grade.

Also from the Gustafson Collection comes a beautiful Fr. 2220-J $5,000 1928 Federal Reserve Note. PMG Extremely Fine 40 that sold for $228,000. One of just two known 1928 Kansas City $5,000s, this extraordinary rarity from an original run of just 720 was acquired by the consignor when Heritage auctioned the massive Taylor Family collection in 2005. Listed at the time in Stephen M. Sullivan’s Small Sized High Denomination Notes as unique, it has since been joined by a PCGS 40 example listed in Track & Price that was sold in 2014.

The Gustafson Collection included several notes bearing the coveted Serial Number 1, including one of just three known Serial Number 1 Fr. 2200-C $500 1928 Dark Green Seal Federal Reserve Note. PMG About Uncirculated 55 notes, which realized $114,000. Heritage experts know of just two other regular serial number 1 examples: a Series 1928 Chicago note that resides in the Smithsonian Institution, and a Series 1934 New York note (a Series 1934 star from Kansas City also could be added to the tiny population). Other serial number 1 notes from the Gustafson Collection included a Serial Number 1 Fr. 1950-K $5 1928 Federal Reserve Note. PMG Gem Uncirculated 66 EPQ that sold for $40,800 and a Serial Number 1 Fr. 2050-F $20 1928 Federal Reserve Note. PMG Choice Uncirculated 63 that brought a winning bid of $21,600.

Fr. 167a $100 1863 Legal Tender PCGS Choice About New 55PPQ
A gorgeous Fr. 167a $100 1863 Legal Tender PCGS Choice About New 55PPQ brought $216,800. A rare and attractive $100 Legal known as the “Spread Eagle” note because of the portrait of the eagle with its wings stretched wide on the obverse, it comes from a Track & Price census population of just 23 serial numbers, a figure that has increased only by one since 2016. But five of those examples are out of reach, with two in the collection of the Smithsonian Institution, and one each in the ANA Museum and in the collections of the Federal Reserve Banks of Chicago and Kansas City, leaving just 18 examples available to collectors.

Always in high demand are notes with exceptionally low serial numbers, like the Serial Number 3 Fr. 2221-B $5,000 1934 Federal Reserve Note. PMG Extremely Fine 40 that prompted more than a dozen bids before it sold for $192,000.

Other top results from the Long Beach Expo Currency auction included, but were not limited to:
Complete results from the currency auction can be found at HA.com/3596.

Back to Top

Renowned Collector’s Trove of Toned Morgan Dollars Offers Eye-Catching Treasures in Heritage’s September 23 Showcase Auction
1883-CC $1 GSA MS66+? Prooflike NGC. CAC. VAM-5B
An exceptional NGC Registry set of GSA Hoard Morgan Dollars from a well-known collector will shimmer in the spotlight in Heritage’s Attractively Toned Morgan GSA Dollar Collection US Coins Showcase Auction September 23.

This 80-lot assemblage comes to Heritage from Jack Kelly, who is known as “Toneddollars” in the NGC Registry. Submitted to NGC for grading or regrading in 2019, most of the coins in the collection received a grade of NGC MS65 or higher, including many that earned the coveted Star Designation for exceptional eye appeal.

“Finely curated collections like this always are a special treat for us to handle,” says Todd Imhof, Executive Vice President at Heritage Auctions. “The level of connoisseurship is inspiring, and the eye appeal of the coins is just stunning. We expect some huge premiums to be executed by our bidders.”

“GSA Hoard” is the name given to a cache of several million silver dollars — the majority of which were Morgan Silver Dollars from the Carson City Mint — that were held in the vaults of the U.S. Treasury Department and later sold by the General Services Administration (GSA) between 1972 and 1980. Coins that have colorful toning, especially rainbow toning and crescent-shaped toning — descriptions that apply to many of Kelly’s coins — are particularly popular among collectors.

The GSA coins rested untouched for years in Treasury and Federal Reserve vaults, largely to back up silver certificates. In 1935, Congress changed the written obligation on silver certificates so the notes could be redeemed “in silver” rather than in “silver dollars” — shortly thereafter, production of the coins was discontinued.

1879-CC $1 GSA MS65+ NGC. VAM-4
In the late 1950s, demand for silver dollars from government vaults began to climb, peaking in the mid-1960s. A 1962 discovery of rare and valuable dates among the millions of dollar coins in Treasury vaults prompted long lines of people seeking silver certificates they wanted to redeem. After discovering numerous bags of rare Carson City Mint (“CC”) dollars, the Treasury stopped redeeming silver certificates with silver dollars, offering bars or granules, instead. Redemption of silver certificates in silver stopped altogether in 1968, although the certificates remain legal tender.

After five sales in 1973 and 1974, more than a million coins — the majority of which were Morgan silver dollars minted at Carson City — were left unsold until 1979 and 1980.

Top highlights in the auction include, but are not limited to:
Images and information about all lots in the auction can be found at HA.com/63299.

Back to Top

The Western Mining Ingot Collection September 29
San Francisco Assay Office Silver Ingot
San Francisco Assay Office Silver Ingot
The Western Mining Ingot Collection is a wide-ranging collection of a few dozen gold and silver (mostly silver) bars and ingots from various eras and makers, accumulated over the course of many years. While many of the bars are relatively modern, there is a dedicated collector base for them, and many are actually quite scarce since they were produced before the 1980s silver spike. As such, the silver bars offered here will sell for well beyond their silver value.

The collectibility of these ingots might best be illustrated by lot 92001, a San Francisco Assay Office Silver Ingot. .999.5 Fine. 7.19 troy ounces. 11mm x 34mm x 57mm. Type I Oval Hallmark, no serial number, straight stem 9s in the fineness stamp. Produced in 1959 before the transition to the round hallmark. The face of the ingot bears the Type I oval hallmark and the fineness 999.5 FINE. The reverse bears the weight without a decimal. The edges are unstamped, with no lot number. A scarce late issue with the Type I hallmark, lacking a serial number stamp. This era of San Francisco ingot is also slightly larger than the previous 5-ounce class Type I hallmark ingots. Light lavender and gray patina characterizes each side. This ingot is already boasting a bid well into four figures despite its relatively slight silver content of 7.19 ounces.

Other interesting ingots offered here include:
This fascinating auction is scheduled for 9PM CT on Sunday, September 29, with bidding ongoing now through Coins.HA.com.

Back to Top

Early Copper & Colonial Coinage Featured in September 23 Showcase Auction
1652 Oak Tree Shilling, Spiny Tree, Noe-14, W-530, Salmon 11a-Gi, R.4, VF30 NGC
1652 Oak Tree Shilling, Spiny Tree, Noe-14, W-530, Salmon 11a-Gi, R.4, VF30 NGC
Our periodic auctions of Early Copper and Colonial Coinage feature the coinage used in the American colonies before American Independence, as well as issues from the earliest days of the country, before the beginnings of the United States Mint. The offerings here serve as a fascinating window into how commerce worked in the very earliest days of the United States. Both half cents and large cents are also well represented in these auctions. The latest offerings in this series of auctions are scheduled to cross the block on Monday, September 23 at 7PM CT, with bidding already open at Coins.HA.com.

The Colonial offerings in this auction are perhaps led by a 1652 Oak Tree Shilling, Spiny Tree, graded VF30 by NGC. Generally regarded as the final Oak Tree shilling prior to introduction of the Pine Tree design, this Noe-14 variety is a recutting of Noe-13 and its intermediate die states. The Spiny Tree variety is a popular Guide Book entry that is listed on page 36 of the 2025 edition. This example is well-centered with the devices almost entirely visible on the smooth, lilac-gray planchet, save for narrow clips at the top and bottom of the flan that crowd the legends. It remains a thoroughly pleasing midgrade example, nearly impossible to surpass in technical quality and eye appeal at the assigned grade.

Some of the other outstanding offerings from the early days of the US include:
Place your bids on these lots exclusively at Coins.HA.com!

Back to Top

Numismatic Literary Guild Honors Heritage Auctions for Best Software, Podcast and Catalogs
Numismatic Literary Guild - Heritage Auctions Platinum Session: World & Ancient Coins won Best World Coins Auction Catalog
Heritage Auctions, the world’s leading auctioneer of coins and currency, has won three 2024 Numismatic Literary Guild (NLG) awards and shared two more, tying for the most such honors for any auction house.

Heritage’s website, www.HA.com/Live, was named the Best Software or App. Heritage’s “Heritage Auctions Unlocking the secret of the World & Ancient Coin Market: What You Need To Know Now!” was honored as the Best Podcast, while Platinum Session: World & Ancient Coins won Best World Coins Auction Catalog.

The Harry W. Bass, Jr. Core Collections, Part IV and The Sydney F. Martin Collection Part IV tied for the Best U.S. Coins Auction Catalog, while The Ibrahim Salem Banknote Collections of World Penninsulas and Islands and The London Chelsea Collections of People’s Bank Banknotes 1948-1980 tied for Best Paper Money (U.S. or World) Auction Catalog; each was tied by Stack’s Bowers, which also had five shared or outright awards.

“Heritage Auctions has been the world’s premiere auctioneer for both coins and currency for years, and these awards justifiably focus the spotlight on those who create our extraordinary catalogs and collateral materials,” says Dustin Johnston, Vice President of Numismatics at Heritage Auctions. “These awards are the result of the incredible work put in by the teams of talented people who come up with so many creative ways to present our coins and currency auctions to the collecting community. Our website is the most comprehensive and user-friendly collectibles website in the auction world, and our catalogs are works of art in their own right, capturing the attention and celebrating the singular assortment of numismatic material offered time after time at Heritage Auctions.”

To be eligible for NLG awards, entries had to be published, released or posted on the Internet between May 1, 2023 and April 30, 2024.

The NLG is a non-profit organization composed of editors, authors, writers, bloggers and content producers who cover news and feature stories about all forms of money, medals and tokens as collectibles.

Back to Top

Help Wanted: Heritage Is Expanding
World & Ancient Coins Department Openings:

Heritage Auctions is seeking candidates to expand the World & Ancient Coin Department. Set your sights on a career with the #1 Numismatic Dealer! Our rapidly growing Ancient and World Coins Department is looking to expand its team to work directly with consignors and buyers, write descriptions for auction catalogs, and process consignments.

Apply today for any of the following positions:
Do you think you have what it takes to join our World & Ancient Coin Department? Send your resume to Jobs@HA.com.


Currency Department Openings:
Apply online today at HA.COM/CAREERS or send us your resume at Jobs@HA.COM.

Back to Top

Around Heritage Auctions
A Chinese Cloisonne Enamel and Gilt Bronze Tripod Censer and Cover
Celebrate Asia Week with Heritage: Tang Dynasty Terracotta, Cloisonné, Original Paintings and Jade Lead the Auction House’s Asian Art Event

Remarkable auctions are shaped by remarkable collections, and Heritage’s September 24 Fine & Decorative Asian Art Signature® Auction is made up of works from more than a dozen distinguished U.S.-based collections of significant objects from Japan, China and beyond. The collections boast collector names that keen-eyed connoisseurs notice when scouring a season’s auction schedule: Ruth Sylvia Nelkin, Princess Maria Romanoff, Dr. John Ross, the Kestenband Collection, and works from the collections of military commanders like James B. Linder and Lu Jingcun lead the fall auction with exquisite works in cloisonné, important ink paintings, jade and jadeite, Tang dynasty terracotta and more.

“With Heritage’s expansion, and the opening of our Tokyo headquarters, our Asian Art category is growing rapidly,” says Moyun Niu, Heritage's Consignment Director of Asian Art. “And in conjunction with this fall’s nationwide Asia Week, we present Heritage’s Asia Week, starting with the extraordinary works in our September 24 auction, and again one day later in our September 25 Japanese Woodblock Prints from The Nelkin Collection Part II Signature® Auction.” The collections represented during the September 25 event have been built over decades by enthusiasts with spectacular taste and a rich history of scholarship. “We are honored to handle these works and to discover the stories that came with them, as well as to conduct further research,” says Charlene Wang, of Heritage’s Fine & Decorative Arts category. “We’re dedicated to the mission of helping our clients either downsize their collections as they move into a new chapter of their lives or acquire and build new collections.”

This exquisite Chinese cloisonné tripod censer from the estate of Ann Alter, dated to the mid-Qing Dynasty, showcases the intricate and labor-intensive cloisonné technique. Its body displays the Eight Buddhist Emblems surrounded by lotus and scrolling foliage and its shoulders are flanked by a pair of gilt dragon-form handles, with each dragon meticulously crafted with five claws — a symbol reserved for the emperor; the censer's elegant form and luxurious materials reflect the high level of craftsmanship associated with imperial commissions. (A similar but slightly smaller example, with a pair of four-clawed dragon handles, can be found in the collection of the RISD Museum.) Ms. Alter acquired this piece in 1975 from the famed Manheim Galleries in the French Quarter of New Orleans. “This exquisite example embodies the exceptional quality of cloisonné enamel,” says Wang.

Read the full press release here.

More information about Asian Art Auctions

Back to Top



Michael Kagan Presents Moonwalker
We Have Liftoff: Michael Kagan’s Limited Edition Screenprint Moonwalker Launches at Heritage Sept. 26

“We can’t do anything if the requirement is that there be no casualties.”

-Isaac Asimov

Heritage Auctions is pleased to announce the exclusive launch, on September 26, of a limited-edition screenprint by Michael Kagan titled Moonwalker. “Launch” is an operative word in this case: The acclaimed New York-based artist, known for his bold and expressive paintings that celebrate the human impulse to explore and push the boundaries of experience via physical stamina and technology, creates jaw-dropping works featuring the intrepid heroes of our age— astronauts, supersonic fighter-jet pilots, mountaineers, and Formula 1 drivers— and this latest work is no exception. Moonwalker draws inspiration from the rich history of NASA's Apollo space missions, and here his suited-up astronaut, standing on the Lunar surface, gazes toward his mission mate who is reflected in his helmet visor.

The work, created in masterful brushwork that pushes into abstraction and then pulls us back to an emotional and material clarity, recalls the iconic imagery that introduced us to the astounding achievements of our space program and the figures who made it happen. The Apollo moonwalkers exemplify the monumental achievements of human spaceflight; their collective journeys have captured the imagination of the world and continue to do so. Kagan’s interpretations of mankind’s riskiest endeavors deliver the psychological impact of those moments and commune with the extraordinary people who risk their lives in the process.

For this exclusive Heritage release, Michael Kagan has partnered with the renowned printmaking studio Brand X Editions. Moonwalker (2024) is a richly colored, hand-printed screenprint on Magnani Incisioni paper in a limited edition of 150, signed and numbered by the artist. This Heritage collaboration with Kagan and Primary Arte will be made available on September 26 at 1 pm Eastern, and Heritage invites you to register and join the waitlist at HA.Com/Moonwalker.

Read the full press release here.

More information about Prints & Multiples Auctions

Back to Top



The Boutique Auctions
More information about Designer Handbags & Luxury Accessories Auctions.

Back to Top

This Week's Top Ten
The ten minor coins from the New Orleans Mint most frequently offered in Heritage auctions:
Edward VIII gold Proof Pattern 5 Pounds 1937 PR67 Ultra Cameo NGC Edward VIII gold Proof Pattern 5 Pounds 1937 PR67 Ultra Cameo NGC
  1. 1854-O half dollar
  2. 1861-O half dollar
  3. 1858-O half dollar
  4. 1855-O half dollar
  5. 1892-O half dollar
  6. 1895-O dime
  7. 1856-O half dollar
  8. 1839-O half dollar
  9. 1892-O quarter
  10. 1908-O half dollar
Do you have a suggestion for a future top ten list?
Send it to us!


Back to Top

Is It Time To Sell?
We are delighted to invite you to consign your U.S. coins to our Dallas auction, scheduled for November 21-24. As an event that attracts the strong attention of numismatists each year, this auction offers an ideal venue for showcasing your collection. With the consignment deadline on October 8, now is the perfect time to prepare your coins for inclusion in this significant event. Our Dallas auctions have been instrumental in bringing together collectors and enthusiasts from all over the country, providing a vibrant marketplace for some of the finest numismatic pieces.

To participate in this exciting event, please contact us at 1-800-835-6000 to consign. Our knowledgeable Consignment Directors are available to guide you through the consignment process, ensuring that your experience is smooth and rewarding. Join us in Dallas this November and let us help you showcase your collection to an engaged and appreciative audience.

November 21-24 US Coins Signature® Auction – Dallas
Consignment Deadline: October 8, 2024

David Mayfield
Vice President, Numismatic Auctions
David@HA.com
1-800-US-COINS ext. 1000


Interested in Selling?
What's My Coin Worth?
Consign to a Heritage Auction

Back to Top

Auction Schedule | Order a Catalog
Back to Top