Heritage Auctions
Comics and Animation News
In This Issue:
Sunday Internet Auction
The Overstreet Comic Book Price Guide Number 1 (Second Article in a Series)
Help Wanted: Comics Grader
Around Heritage Auctions
Cover of the Week: Plenty of Fish in the … Sewer?
Current Auctions
December 19, 2018
Sunday Internet Auction
Sunday Internet Comics Auction
Auction Ends:
December 23, 2018
Live Session at 6:00 PM CT

Our Peanuts selection includes some of their earliest comic book appearances. Eighteen CGC-Graded Giant-Size Marvels are in the auction. And we have 16 of the 20 issues published in Street & Smith's Doc Savage series.
Tip Top Comics #185 (United Feature Syndicate/Standard, 1954) CGC VG+ 4.5 Off-white to white pages
One of just a few early appearances to have Peanuts as the main cover feature.
Giant-Size Spider-Man #4 (Marvel, 1975) CGC NM/MT 9.8 White pages
The third appearance of the Punisher.
Doc Savage Comics #1 (Street & Smith, 1940) Condition: Apparent VG
The first issue has a Gerber scarcity rating of 7.


Highlights of this week's auction include:

Mickey's Fire Brigade Mickey Mouse Animation Drawing (Walt Disney, 1935) Mickey's Fire Brigade Mickey Mouse Animation Drawing (Walt Disney, 1935)
Fire chief Mickey, in his #1 fireman's helmet, is all wrapped up in his work in this original 12 field 5-peghole animation drawing. This cartoon, directed by Ben Sharpsteen, was first shown in theaters on 8/3/35. The art is in graphite with nice green and red highlights, and an image size of 4". The number 25 is written in the lower right corner. Edge wear, with a small tear along the right side, and a small amount of paper loss in the upper left corner, all well away from the image; Very Good condition.
View
Looney Tunes and Merrie Melodies Comics #4 (Dell, 1942) CGC NM- 9.2 Off-white pages Looney Tunes and Merrie Melodies Comics #4 (Dell, 1942) CGC NM- 9.2 Off-white pages
Walt Kelly art. This is the highest-graded copy certified by CGC to date, as well as the nicest copy we've had the opportunity to offer. Overstreet 2018 NM- 9.2 value = $3,400. CGC census 12/18: 1 in 9.2, none higher.
View
Popular Comics #101 Mile High Pedigree (Dell, 1944) CGC NM- 9.2 Off-white to white pages Popular Comics #101 Mile High Pedigree (Dell, 1944) CGC NM- 9.2 Off-white to white pages
War Bond cover. Overstreet 2018 NM- 9.2 value = $120. CGC census 12/18: 2 in 9.2, 1 higher.
View
Strange Tales #110 (Marvel, 1963) CGC FN+ 6.5 Off-white pages Strange Tales #110 (Marvel, 1963) CGC FN+ 6.5 Off-white pages
First appearances of Doctor Strange, the Ancient One, Nightmare, and Wong. First Paste-Pot Pete and Wizard team-up. Currently ranked #21 on Overstreet's Top 50 Silver Age Comics list. Jack Kirby cover. Dick Ayers and Steve Ditko art. Overstreet 2018 FN 6.0 value = $2,400; VF 8.0 value = $5,600. CGC census 12/18: 78 in 6.5, 287 higher.
View
Russ Manning Magnus, Robot Fighter #15 Complete 1-Page Story '1A - The Wise One' Original Art (Gold Key, 1966) Russ Manning Magnus, Robot Fighter #15 Complete 1-Page Story "1A - The Wise One" Original Art (Gold Key, 1966)
This 1-page story appeared on the inside front cover of the issue, and it recaps Magnus' origin and how he was raised by the benevolent robot 1A. The page was created in ink over graphite on Bristol board with an image area of 12" x 16.5". The title is presstype paste-up. There is a bit of missing paste-up in the title panel, leaving glue residue behind, and there are staple holes in the upper left margin. In Very Good condition.
View
The Incredible Hulk #181 (Marvel, 1974) CGC NM- 9.2 White pages The Incredible Hulk #181 (Marvel, 1974) CGC NM- 9.2 White pages
First full appearance of Wolverine. Wendigo appearance. Herb Trimpe cover and art. Currently tied for #2 on Overstreet's list of Top 25 Bronze Age Comics. Overstreet 2018 NM- 9.2 value = $4,200. CGC census 12/18: 584 in 9.2, 834 higher.
View
Marvel Superhero 7-11 Plastic Slurpee Cups Group of 36 (Southland/Marvel, 1977) Marvel Superhero 7-11 Plastic Slurpee Cups Group of 36 (Southland/Marvel, 1977)
This cool group includes 36 Slurpee Cups from 1977, with no duplication. Characters represented include Captain and Ms. Marvel. Daredevil, Fantastic Four, Conan, Hulk, Thor, Iron Man, Dr. Strange, Silver Surfer, Spider-Man, X-Men, the Inhumans, Captain America, the Avengers, Howard the Duck, Black Panther, the Champions, Nova, Dr. Doom, Iron Fist, Black Widow, Red Sonja, and Shang-Chi. While there is no exact duplication, several of the more popular characters had different cups made. In Excellent condition, with very minor signs of storage wear.
View
Dick Dillin and Frank McLaughlin Justice League of America #157 Story Page 1 Original Art (DC, 1978) Dick Dillin and Frank McLaughlin Justice League of America #157 Story Page 1 Original Art (DC, 1978)
The Goddess of Love, Mauri, makes her return in this issue as she plans to enact her revenge against the Justice League. The page also features Superman, Batman, Flash, Green Lantern, Black Canary, Green Arrow, and Elongated Man! Done in ink over graphite on Bristol board with an image area of 10" x 15" (including indicia). The page is toned with production tape residue in the top and bottom margins, a text paste-up in the top left, and a text correction in the top left. In Very Good condition.
View
John Byrne and Joe Rubinstein Official Handbook of the Marvel Universe #9 Page 18 'Sasquatch' of Alpha Flight Illustration Original Art (Marvel, 1983) John Byrne and Joe Rubinstein Official Handbook of the Marvel Universe #9 Page 18 "Sasquatch" of Alpha Flight Illustration Original Art (Marvel, 1983)
After an experiment with Gamma radiation, Walter Langkowski found he could transform himself into a legendary "Big Foot"...aka Sasquatch! An early member of Alpha Flight, he stuck with the team through many iterations. He towers 13.5" tall and nearly 10" wide on this illustration by his creator John Byrne. The piece was rendered in ink over graphite on Marvel Bristol board. The piece has been sunstruck from a previous frame job and is in Very Good condition.
View
William Van Horn Anders And & Co. [Donald Duck and Company] #1994-41 Story Page 18 Original Art (Egmont, 1994) William Van Horn Anders And & Co. [Donald Duck and Company] #1994-41 Story Page 18 Original Art (Egmont, 1994)
A key-page from the story "Horsing Around with History" featuring Uncle Scrooge, Donald Duck, and the nephews, which was first published in Denmark and Norway, then in many other countries before being reprinted in Uncle Scrooge Adventures #33 in 1995. The last panel of this page served as cover inspiration for several foreign editions (including Germany, Greece, and France). The page is created in ink on two sheets of bright white conjoined Bristol board with a combined image area of 16.25" x 23.25". They are joined with tape on the backside. Signed by Van Horn in the lower margin. In Excellent condition.
View

Our MyHeritage: MyBids feature makes tracking your favorite items easier than ever. Just a reminder...our Sunday Internet Comics, Animation, and Art Auctions end with a Live Session at 6:00 PM CT.

Browse the entire auction here.

Back to Top

The Overstreet Comic Book Price Guide Number 1 (Second Article in a Series)
By David Stone, Heritage Auctions

Bob Overstreet published the first edition of the Overstreet Comic Book Price Guide (OPG) in November of 1970. Overstreet reports that he believed the OPG would be a one-shot and did not anticipate turning out yearly updated editions until later. Curiously, however, the first edition was numbered, so the possibility of future editions must at least have been in the back of his mind. Sales were brisk, so a second printing, with a few corrections and a blue cover, was accomplished in 1971 (see covers below).

The Comic Book Price Guide First Edition 1993-Present

In his introduction to OPG #1, Bob Overstreet notes it would have been impractical to produce a price guide for comic books at an earlier time, as the market in the 1960s was very volatile, with constantly changing prices and only a rudimentary grading system. While comic book fandom largely grew out of the long-established science fiction fandom, the grading system was largely borrowed from coin collecting. The grade Very Fine was not listed in OPG #1 (it was added in 1977), and prices were given for copies in Good, Fine, and Mint condition. The most expensive comic book listed in OPG #1 was Action Comics #1, at $300 in Mint, closely followed by Detective Comics #27, at $275. The content of the two printings was very similar, but the second printing is missing Ken Mitchell's advertisement and Jerry Bails' offering of his important index, the Collector's Guide: The First Heroic Age, on the last page (this page is blank in the blue cover edition).

Overstreet advertised in most of the popular fan publications of the time (see ad for the white cover first printing in the Rocket's Blast and Comic Collector #76 below).

The Comic Book Price Guide First Edition 1993-Present

The ad for the blue cover second printing in the Oct-Nov 1971 edition of Comic Zine (see below).

The Comic Book Price Guide First Edition 1993-Present

And the ad for the second printing, with a plug for the upcoming second edition, in the Rocket's Blast and Comic Collector #85 (see below).

The Comic Book Price Guide First Edition 1993-Present

The first printing (white cover, November 1970) had a print run of 1,000 copies, while the second printing (blue cover) had a print run of 800 copies. More copies of the blue cover edition are seen today, perhaps because the white cover first printing was more heavily used by dealers and collectors at the time of issue, while the blue cover second printing was more likely to be preserved by collectors. Alternatively, some sources indicate the second printing had a higher than reported print run, perhaps as high as 1,200 examples, but that figure is undocumented. Both editions were easily unbound, as the 242-page book was just stapled together in a saddle-stitched fashion (Bob Overstreet and his family collated the books and stapled them together themselves). Exactly how many copies of each printing have survived is unknown. Certainly many copies have changed hands over the years in both public and private transactions, but records of these sales are seldom available. Since CGC only recently began to certify the OPG #1, no meaningful Census data is available. Old-time collectors believe as many as 200 copies of the white cover first printing may be extant in collectible condition. We have seen 37 different copies offered publicly in the last 15 years, some of them more than once. So far, we have only been able to trace three examples in Near Mint condition, but others likely exist. The record price realized for a white cover OPG #1 was recently set by the 9.2 NM CGC certified example in lot 92312 of the Comics and Comic Art Signature Auction (Heritage, 11/2018), which brought $9,000, including the buyer's premium.

To be continued in a future newsletter. The previous article in this series can be found here.

Back to Top

Help Wanted: Comics Grader
Do you have knowledge of Silver and Golden Age comic books? Then apply your analytical and research skills in our unique and fun environment. Heritage Auctions, a well-established auction house with over 40 years of longevity, is seeking a talented Comic Grader to join our Comics Department in Dallas. Heritage Auctions (HA.com) is the third largest and one of the fastest growing auction houses in the world. Heritage Auctions sales in addition to fine jewelry include: luxury accessories, watches, wine, coins, books and manuscripts, modern & contemporary art, American and European art, decorative arts, entertainment, music, and many more.

More information about this position can be found here.

Apply with us today online or via email at Experts@HA.com

Back to Top

Intelligent Collector Subscribe Today


Around Heritage Auctions
Groundbreaking New Benefit at Heritage Auctions: Make Offer to Owner Archive

Heritage Auctions' Make Offer to Owner (MOtO) program, through which clients can make anonymous offers on lots previously sold at auction, has added an extremely useful new feature showing the amount and status of every resale offer ever made via HA.com.

Moto Archive
Any Heritage member who sees a previously auctioned item of interest with a Make Offer to Owner button has the option of submitting an offer, after which the item's owner can accept or decline the offer, or submit a counter-offer to the potential buyer. The new Make Offer to Owner Archive is sortable by Category as well as by Accepted, Rejected and Pending status. The Archive includes every MOtO offer made via HA.com since the feature was introduced first in 2009, with the most recent offers appearing first.

"This new, permanent archive increases our already market-leading transparency," said Heritage Auctions Co-Chairman Jim Halperin, "and we hope it will encourage more MOtO competition on previously auctioned items by showing pending offers in one convenient place. Just type 'HA.com/moto' into your browser to access the main MOtO Archive page anytime, then pick a category and refine the list to see Pending, Rejected, Accepted or All offers. Our members will be amazed at how much information they can glean by accessing their favorite categories on a daily basis. Every listing includes a link to the entire item page. Members are encouraged to outbid any and all pending MOtO offers if they would pay more for that item than the pending high offer."

Heritage's MOtO program has become increasingly popular with both sellers and buyers. Most members who have made a purchase through the program have bought, or at least made offers, again. Using the program offers clients an added measure of security and comfort about the authenticity of a lot that cannot be replicated through a secondary outside seller.

The program has enjoyed tremendous growth, with combined sales in 2017 and 2018 - the program's two most successful years - of more than $16 million. The MOtO program has been particularly popular among Sports and Comics collectors.

Back to Top

Cover of the Week: Plenty of Fish in the...Sewer?
Detective Comics #229 (DC, 1956) CGC VG+ 4.5 Off-white pages

A sewer with fish in it seems implausible to us, but then we thought sewer water was dark and murky. Also, we never ceased to be impressed at what sharp dressers 1950s hoods were!

This is the cover of Detective Comics #229, by Win Mortimer. You can bid on a VG+ copy here.

Back to Top

Current Auctions
Comic & Comic Art Auctions
Sunday Internet Comics Auction
Sunday Comics
December 23
Live session @ 6PM CT
OTHER SIGNATURE
AUCTIONS
NYINC World Coins - Jan. 6-7
Salado, TX Estate - Jan. 9
FUN US Coins - Jan. 9-14
FUN World Currency - Jan. 9-14
FUN World Currency - Jan. 10-14
"Say it Loud" The John Silverstein Collection of African American Social History - Jan. 15
Internet World Coins -
Jan. 15-16

OTHER INTERNET
AUCTIONS
Weekly Prints & Multiples -
Dec. 19

Thur. Natural History - Dec. 20
Thur. World Coins - Dec. 20
Sun. Sports - Dec. 23
Sun. Movie Posters - Dec. 23
Tues. Currency - Dec. 25
Tues. Jewelry - Dec. 25
Weekly US Coins - Dec. 25-26
Auction Schedule | Order a Catalog
Back to Top