Heritage Auctions
Comics and Animation News
In This Issue:
Sunday Internet Auction
Predecessors of The Overstreet Comic Book Price Guide (First in a Series)
Around Heritage Auctions
Cover of the Week: We'll Always Have All True Romance #18
Current Auctions
October 10, 2018
Sunday Internet Auction
Sunday Internet Comics Auction
Auction Ends:
October 14, 2018
Live Session at 6:00 PM CT

No less than seven John Buscema art pages are in this week's auction! We've got a nice selection of Donald Duck animation drawings from the 1930s and 1940s. And you have plenty of Golden Age teen humor books to choose from this week.
John Buscema and Ernie Chan Conan the Barbarian #95 Story Page 16 Original Art (Marvel, 1979)
Hyborian action from Conan the Barbarian #95.
Orphan's Picnic Donald Duck Animation Drawing (Walt Disney, 1936)
Donald still had a longer bill in Orphan's Picnic (1936).
Patsy Walker #38 Davis Crippen ('D' Copy) Pedigree (Atlas, 1952) Condition: VF/NM
Future Mad artist Al Jaffee drew the cover of Patsy Walker #38.


Highlights of this week's auction include:

Detective Comics #49 (DC, 1941) CGC FN 6.0 Off-white to white pages Detective Comics #49 (DC, 1941) CGC FN 6.0 Off-white to white pages
Clayface appearance. Batman and Robin cover and art by Bob Kane and Jerry Robinson. Overstreet 2018 FN 6.0 value = $1,062. CGC census 10/18: 4 in 6.0, 19 higher.
View
Marvel Mystery Comics #73 (Timely, 1946) Condition: VG- Marvel Mystery Comics #73 (Timely, 1946) Condition: VG-
Vince Alascia cover. Charles Nicholas and Al Gabriele art. Overstreet 2018 VG 4.0 value = $322. From the Kevin Michael McFadden Collection.
View
Famous Funnies #212 (Eastern Color, 1954) CGC VG+ 4.5 Off-white to white pages Famous Funnies #212 (Eastern Color, 1954) CGC VG+ 4.5 Off-white to white pages
Frank Frazetta flying saucer, bondage cover. Overstreet 2018 VG 4.0 value = $374. CGC census 10/18: 5 in 4.5, 41 higher.
View
Amazing Fantasy #15 (Marvel, 1962) CGC Apparent FN 6.0 Moderate (P) Off-white pages Amazing Fantasy #15 (Marvel, 1962) CGC Apparent FN 6.0 Moderate (P) Off-white pages
The origin and first appearance of Spider-Man, and the first appearances of Uncle Ben and Aunt May. Jack Kirby and Steve Ditko cover and art. Currently ranks #1 on Overstreet's list of Top 50 Silver Age Comics. CGC notes, "Restoration includes: color touch, pieces added, tear seals, cleaned reinforced." Overstreet 2018 GD 2.0 value = $8,000; VG 4.0 value = $16,000; FN 6.0 value = $32,000.
View
Bill Ward Cracked #81 Complete 2-page Story 'Cracked Takes a Look at Night Clubs' Original Art (Major Magazines, 1969) Bill Ward Cracked #81 Complete 2-page Story "Cracked Takes a Look at Night Clubs" Original Art (Major Magazines, 1969)
Ward brings almost an Underground Comix sensibility to this large-scale MAD-style spread, razzing the various types of personality that one finds in a nightclub. Ink and watercolors (grayscale) on Bristol board. Image area, 25" x 14.5". The art is missing many of its word balloon stats (leaving stained residual glue), and there is heavy edge wear and some tearing. In Good condition.
View
Marvel Giant-Size X Men 1 (Marvel, 1975) CGC NM+ 9.6 White pages Marvel Giant-Size X Men 1 (Marvel, 1975) CGC NM+ 9.6 White pages
First appearance of the new X-Men. First appearances of Storm, Nightcrawler, Colossus, and Thunderbird. Second full appearance of Wolverine. Gil Kane cover. Overstreet 2018 NM- 9.2 value = $1,700. CGC census 10/18: 315 in 9.6, 148 higher.
View
Frank Thorne Marvel Feature V2#2 Story Page 9 Original Art (Marvel, 1976) Frank Thorne Marvel Feature V2#2 Story Page 9 Original Art (Marvel, 1976)
A down in the dumps Red Sonja is deep in thought as she rethinks the vow she took as a young woman. Created in ink over graphite on Bristol board with an image area of 10" x 15". The page is slightly toned, with glue residue in the bottom margin from a missing paste-up, and a whiteout text correction in Panel 2; otherwise in Excellent condition.
View
The Avengers #196 (Marvel, 1980) CGC NM/MT 9.8 White pages The Avengers #196 (Marvel, 1980) CGC NM/MT 9.8 White pages
The Taskmaster, in his first full appearance and origin issue. George Perez cover. Overstreet 2018 NM- 9.2 value = $95. CGC census 10/18: 142 in 9.8, none higher.
View
The Batman Adventures #12 (DC, 1993) CGC NM+ 9.6 White pages The Batman Adventures #12 (DC, 1993) CGC NM+ 9.6 White pages
This first appearance of Harley Quinn in comics (albeit outside of DC continuity) is one of the most desirable comics to come out of the 1990s, and it regularly sells for well above Guide values. Currently the #4 book on Overstreet's list of Top 20 Modern Age Comics. Mike Parobeck cover and art. Overstreet 2018 NM- 9.2 value = $475. CGC census 10/18: 993 in 9.6, 656 higher.
View

Our MyHeritage: MyBids feature makes tracking your favorite items easier than ever. Just a reminder...our Sunday Internet Comics, Animation, and Art Auctions end with a Live Session at 6:00 PM CT.

Browse the entire auction here.

Back to Top

Predecessors of The Overstreet Comic Book Price Guide (First in a Series)
By David Stone, Heritage Auctions

Overstreet Guide 1
The Overstreet Comic Book Price Guide (OPG) has been the "Bible" of comic book fandom since its inception in 1970. It has had a profound effect on all aspects of the hobby, making publication and pricing information on comic books and related items available to collectors throughout the world. It greatly encouraged the growth of independent comic shops in the 1970s and helped establish the direct market distribution system. Surprisingly, for such an important hobby influence, the OPG has not been studied extensively by most collectors. This article is the first in a series that seeks to explore the rich and complex history of the OPG.

Bob Overstreet always said the inspiration for the Overstreet Comic Book Price Guide was the Guide Book of United States Coins, issued every year by Whitman Publishing. Overstreet avidly collected coins from circulation, arrow heads, and other items in his younger days, along with comic books (see Bob's Bizarre Tales in OPG number 30 for an account of his early comic collecting activities and The Semi-Secret Origins of the Overstreet Comic Book Price Guide in OPG number 37 for his other hobby pursuits). However, there were some publications from early comic book fandom that must have had an influence on his thinking.

Overstreet saved all the price lists put out by early comic book dealers, like Jerry Bails and Howard Rogofsky, and he saved all the back issues of the Rocket's Blast and Comic Collector, and other early fanzines he acquired over the years. These early publications provided much of the raw data he would incorporate into the first edition of the OPG.

Although he has not mentioned it in interviews, and may not have been aware of it at the time, there was another comic book price guide that predated OPG #1 by five years. The Argosy Comic Book Price Guide was written by Michael Cohen and Tom Horsky and published by the Argosy Bookshop in Los Angeles in 1965 (see image #1). It was 36 pages long and provided prices for 5,000 Golden Age and early Silver Age comic books in Mint condition. It is possible that Overstreet was not aware of this publication when he published OPG #1, as it had a very small distribution and experts agree fewer than 50 copies are extant. However, the Argosy Price Guide was advertised in the Rockets Blast and Comic Collector, which Overstreet studied extensively in preparation for OPG #1 (see ad in Rocket's Blast and Comic Collector #42 below). Whether this guide played any part in Overstreet's development of the OPG or not, he certainly became aware of it at some point, because a Near Mint copy of the Argosy Price Guide from the Robert M. Overstreet Collection sold at an auction on July 25, 2013 for $2,150.50.

One influence Overstreet repeatedly acknowledged was fandom legend Jerry Bails. In fact, Overstreet tried to get Bails to write and publish a comic book price guide, but Bails was too busy to take on the project. As early as 1963, Bails had begun indexing Golden Age comics in publications like An Authoritative Index of DC Comics (see image #2).

Overstreet Guide 2

#1
Overstreet Guide 3

#2
His research culminated in the Collector's Guide: The First Heroic Age, published in 1969, an index of all costume and super hero comic books published between 1934 and 1947 (see image #3).

Before this index, collectors had no clear idea of exactly which comic books had been published in the Golden Age. No pricing information was included in the index, but many details about major story lines, first appearances, and artists were summarized. Bails sometimes untangled the bewildering numbering systems of some comic book series, which often stopped and started again in non-consecutive order. Of course, this early effort was far from comprehensive, and important non-super hero publications, like Famous Funnies, were omitted entirely. It was a good place to start, however, and Bails generously shared his research with Overstreet and strongly encouraged him to publish the OPG, which he finally decided to do himself. In some early advertisements for OPG number 1, Bails is listed as an Associate Editor (see image #4).

(To be continued in a future newsletter.)

Overstreet Guide 4

#3
Overstreet Guide 5

#4

Overstreet Guide 5

Detail of image #4.
Back to Top

Around Heritage Auctions
Swed Menorahs Among Prized Judaica in Heritage Auctions' Silver & Vertu Auction

Yossi Swed Partial Gilt Silver Ship-Form Menorah
Three extraordinary silver Menorahs by one of the world's elite silversmiths are being offered in Heritage Auctions' Silver & Vertu Auction Oct. 15 in Dallas.

"Following tremendous attention on Yossi Swed's works in our April auction, we are pleased to have the opportunity to present more of his masterworks in silver," Heritage Auctions Silver & Decorative Art Director Karen Rigdon said. "Based in Israel, Swed's workshop creates highly detailed objects that delight young and old alike."

A Yossi Swed Partial Gilt Silver Ship-Form Menorah with Display Case, 20th century (estimate: $25,000-35,000) includes elaborate mechanical workings. A turning ship's wheel glides a cannon from the starboard side, and eight of the nine cannon handles on deck lock and unlock each cannon separately, allowing a different configuration for each night of Hanukkah. The anchor is formed as a dreidel, presented in glazed brass fitted vitrine.

A Yossi Swed Partial Gilt Silver Menorah, 20th century (estimate: $20,000-15,000) is an altar form with eight lamps that tilt by turning the right oiler, which is seated on a candleholder. Side wings in the base house a dreidel and wick storage, a back door hides lamp tools and a center tray can be removed for cleaning. The front features a Hebrew inscription that reads, "These candles are sanctified, and we do not have permission to make ordinary use of them."

A Yossi Swed Partial Gilt Silver and Glass Menorah, 20th century (estimate: $8,000-10,000) is a gorgeous silver and glass Menorah with a latched case that holds eight oil lamps, an oil ewer and a tankard. The case crown has two secret ends with nine bobeches (cups) to convert lamps to candleholders and a dreidel, with a pair of matching chimneys that serve as the bases for the handle.

The Swed workshop houses Master of design, metalwork and engineering under one roof, thereby creating each work piece by piece. The design and process allow for easy cleaning, polishing and rhodium plating, a process that is used, especially on jewelry and most often on white gold, to provide a surface that will resist scratches and tarnish and give a white, reflective appearance.

More information about Fine Art Auctions

Back to Top

Cover of the Week: We'll Always Have All True Romance #18


The country of France has over 200,000 square miles, but oddly, the only part of it American comic characters of the last 70 years have ever visited is a 100-yard radius of the Eiffel tower.

All True Romance #18 (Comic Media, 1954) CGC GD+ 2.5 Off-white pages

A case in point is All True Romance #18. You can bid on a CGC-graded copy here.



Back to Top

Current Auctions
Comic & Comic Art Auctions
October 17 Ed Asner Family Center Fundraiser Internet Comic Art Auction #121892
October 17 Ed Asner Family Center Fundraiser Internet Comic Art Auction #121892
View Lots
Sunday Internet Comics Auction
Sunday Comics
October 14
Live session @ 6PM CT
OTHER SIGNATURE
AUCTIONS
US Coins Signature - Oct. 11-14
Photographs Signature - Oct. 12
Illustration Art - Oct. 12
Silver & Vertu - Oct. 15
Fall Sports Memorabilia Catalog -
Oct. 18-19

Design - Oct. 21
Modern & Contemporary Prints & Multiples - Oct. 22
Venice, Florida Estate - Oct. 23
Watches & Fine Timepieces - Oct. 24
Historical Manuscripts - Oct. 25
The Feeling Good Collection, Part II Currency - Oct. 28
The Feeling Good Collection, Part II World & Ancient Coin - Oct. 28
The Toy Collection of Ronnie K. Pirovino - Nov. 7
Eric P. Newman Collection Part X - Nov. 7-10
American Art - Nov. 8
OTHER INTERNET
AUCTIONS
Thur. World Coins - Oct. 11
Thurs. Natural History - Oct. 11
Sun. Movie Posters - Oct. 14
Sun. Sports - Oct. 14
Tues. Currency - Oct. 16
Tues. Jewelry - Oct. 16
Weekly US Coins - Oct. 16-17
Auction Schedule | Order a Catalog
Back to Top